The Instigator
kllrbeanz90
Pro (for)
Tied
0 Points
The Contender
KIng_Bob
Con (against)
Tied
0 Points

Mace Windu Should Return

Do you like this debate?NoYes+1
Add this debate to Google Add this debate to Delicious Add this debate to FaceBook Add this debate to Digg  
Post Voting Period
The voting period for this debate has ended.
after 0 votes the winner is...
It's a Tie!
Voting Style: Open Point System: Select Winner
Started: 12/14/2018 Category: Movies
Updated: 3 years ago Status: Post Voting Period
Viewed: 672 times Debate No: 119485
Debate Rounds (3)
Comments (1)
Votes (0)

 

kllrbeanz90

Pro

Mace Windu needs to return to the Star Wars films. Being the fact he was second in command to Yoda, He is a very powerful Jedi and there are many factors to cause his survival like simply landing on a speeder, Using the force to catch himself, And many more imaginable.

Samuel L. Jackson even begged for it at Star Wars Celebration Orlando 2017. He made a claim that we have seen many characters coming back after losing a hand, And that there were many other factors that could lead to his return.

Check out this short 1 minute video and be sure this is a battle you want to take part in. Not bringing Mace back will not just effect the men, But the women, And the children too.

https://www. Youtube. Com/watch? V=z6933n3anMc
KIng_Bob

Con

Mace is dead. Sad, But true. We all saw him get both electrocuted by Sidious's sith lightning, And then get thrown a thousand stories down to the surface. Maybe he could have saved himself from the fall, But as he had just been shocked really badly he was in no condition to do anything to help himself. He is dead, No ifs, Ands, Or buts about it. Besides, Where would he fit in the movies? Rey is the last Jedi, Remember? Because of that, He couldn't play a major role anyway. Besides, Samuel L. Jackson is super old now.
Debate Round No. 1
kllrbeanz90

Pro

While you make an outstanding point about Rey being the last Jedi, There could always be the secret that they didn't realize Mace was still alive. Mace Windu is a powerful Jedi and I know he could have saved himself. Did you even watch that 1 minute clip I attached? It explains my point about Mace Windu surviving. Mace Windu lives on. Just like we saw with Ashoka, When everyone began to accept the fact she was dead, Poof, She pops back into Rebels.

While I respect your arguement, I'm sorry to say that
You have lost my lord
KIng_Bob

Con

Okay, For starters we never even were supposed to think that Asoka died, She just left the jedi. Clone Wars isn't even canon anymore. I explained why he couldn't save himself, He had just been shocked into unconsciousness by Darth Sidious. And the chances of landing on a landspeeder (and holding on while unconscious) are slim to none. We have to accept the fact that he is dead and not coming back.
Debate Round No. 2
kllrbeanz90

Pro

That's outrageous. Yes he struck by Palpatine's force lightening but it's Mace Windu, He doesn't just die. Everyone wants to see the return of Master Windu and Samuel L Jackson more than the fans. The chances of him landing on a speeder are actually high young padawan. If you'll take notice, There are thousands of speeders whizzing by the entire scene. We have seen it many times in the Clone Wars series where the jedi have made the landing on moving objects even when hurt and tired. It can be done young one. The Force is strong with Master Windu and it is for these reasons that Master Windu lives on.

Besides those facts listed, Lets go even further. Anakin lost an arm, Both legs, Was burned by lava, And still lived, We also saw Anakin jump out of his speeder, Fall a long time and land on Zam's speeder, Obi-Wan was blasted off a high cliff during Order 66 and he still lived, And Yoda was blasted with Palpatine's force lightening and fell a couple stories hitting some senate pods along the way and he still lived, What's to stop Mace Windu from simply catching a speeder on his way down and surviving?

We can take it a step further with catching himself with the Force. In The Phantom Menace, We see Obi-Wan lift himself out of the pit by only focusing on Qui-Gon's lightsaber and slicing Maul and in the Last Jedi we see Luke catch himself with the Force to keep from falling down when battling Rey. Now, Knowing Mace Windu is more powerful Jedi than either one of them, Explain your logic now young padawan. All these factors have played out proving it can be done and with Mace Windu being a powerful Jedi Master, One of these factors could have easily taken place. I know you just want to believe he's dead to try to stick to cannon, But you're wrong, Mace Windu is alive and is in hiding, Awaiting the right time to make his survival known to the galaxy.

So, I'm sorry but YOU HAVE LOST MY LORD. . . . .
KIng_Bob

Con

Okay, That's all true. But, When they saved themselves, They weren't unconscious, Handless, Falling through the air at incredible speed, And exausted after a prolonged battle with a powerful sith lord. Even if he landed on a speeder, He had his hands chopped off and would not be able to hang on. Also, If he was 50 year old when he was chucked out a window, He would be like 115 years old now. Mace is a famously good duelist, Not known for being otherwise strong with the force.
Debate Round No. 3
1 comment has been posted on this debate.
Posted by KIng_Bob 3 years ago
KIng_Bob
I WILL BE VICTORIOUS! Yay.
No votes have been placed for this debate.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use.